LLMSkillHub
mirroredCopied from undefined-ui/second-brain-os under MIT. undefined-ui has not claimed this page, and is not affiliated with LLM SkillHub.

undefined-ui / goal-test

Turn a vague task into a testable definition of done and generate an executable goal-test script for it, optionally with a bounded retry loop around a headless agent. Use when the user wants to run an agent in a loop, asks how to know when an agent task is finished, or says a goal like "improve X" needs to become checkable. Do NOT use for building eval suites over many cases — that is evals-bootstrap.

0
SKILL.md
3.0 KB

Write done as a script

Theory: The four parts of a loop
and the goal test build page.
"Improve the error handling" cannot terminate a loop, because nothing can ever
say it is finished. The goal must be phrased so that a program — not a person,
not the model — returns true or false against it.

Workflow

  1. Extract the claim. Ask what the user wants true at the end, then
    restate it as verifiable facts: which command exits 0, which file exists,
    which string appears, which number crosses which threshold. If a part
    cannot be checked by a program, say so and negotiate it down to what can.

  2. Prefer checks that already exist. The test suite, the linter, the
    build, the type checker. A goal test that shells out to make test is
    better than one that reimplements it.

  3. Write goal-test.sh (or .py if the checks are easier there) in the
    project root: runs every check, prints one line per check with pass/fail,
    exits 0 only when all pass. Keep it under ~40 lines; it must run in
    seconds and be safe to run repeatedly.

  4. Run it now. It should fail before the work is done — a goal test that
    passes on the current state is testing nothing. Show the failing output.

  5. Offer the loop. If the user wants the agent driven until done, wrap it:
#!/usr/bin/env bash
# goal-loop.sh — run a headless agent until the goal test passes or attempts run out.
set -u
MAX_ATTEMPTS=5
for i in $(seq 1 "$MAX_ATTEMPTS"); do
  FEEDBACK=$(./goal-test.sh 2>&1) && { echo "done in $i attempt(s)"; exit 0; }
  claude -p "Goal: <the goal>. The goal test currently fails with:
$FEEDBACK
Fix the code so the goal test passes." \
    --permission-mode acceptEdits --output-format json > ".attempt-$i.json"
done
echo "goal test still failing after $MAX_ATTEMPTS attempts — falling back to a human"
exit 1

Adjust the agent command to whatever CLI the user runs. Keep the three
brakes visible and named: the checker outside the model (goal-test.sh),
the stop rule (test passes), the budget (MAX_ATTEMPTS, plus a dollar cap
read from the JSON output if they want one).

Rules

  • The checker never asks the model's opinion; self-review is not a checker.
  • Feed the checker's output back verbatim — the failure text is the prompt.

  • If the user cannot state done as a check, they do not have a loopable task
    yet; tell them that plainly and suggest an interactive session instead.